Journal cover Journal topic
Climate of the Past An interactive open-access journal of the European Geosciences Union
Journal topic
CP | Articles | Volume 15, issue 4
Clim. Past, 15, 1581–1601, 2019
© Author(s) 2019. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Clim. Past, 15, 1581–1601, 2019
© Author(s) 2019. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.

Research article 13 Aug 2019

Research article | 13 Aug 2019

Dynamic climate-driven controls on the deposition of the Kimmeridge Clay Formation in the Cleveland Basin, Yorkshire, UK

Dynamic climate-driven controls on the deposition of the Kimmeridge Clay Formation in the...
Elizabeth Atar1, Christian März2, Andrew C. Aplin1, Olaf Dellwig3, Liam G. Herringshaw4, Violaine Lamoureux-Var5, Melanie J. Leng6,7, Bernhard Schnetger8, and Thomas Wagner9 Elizabeth Atar et al.
  • 1Department of Earth Sciences, Durham University, South Road, Durham, DH1 3LE, UK
  • 2School of Earth and Environment, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
  • 3Leibniz-Institute for Baltic Sea Research, Marine Geology, Seestrasse 15, 18119 Rostock, Germany
  • 4School of Environmental Sciences, University of Hull, Hull, HU6 7RX, UK
  • 5IFP Energies Nouvelles, Geosciences Division, 1 et 4 Avenue de Bois-Préau, 92852 Rueil-Malmaison Cedex, France
  • 6National Environmental Isotope Facility, British Geological Survey, Nottingham, NG12 5GG, UK
  • 7Centre for Environmental Geochemistry, School of Biosciences, University of Nottingham, Sutton Bonington Campus, Leicestershire, UK
  • 8ICMB, Oldenburg University, P.O. Box 2503, 26111 Oldenburg, Germany
  • 9Lyell Centre, Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh, EH14 4AS, UK
Back to toptop

The Kimmeridge Clay Formation (KCF) is a laterally extensive, total-organic-carbon-rich succession deposited throughout northwest Europe during the Kimmeridgian–Tithonian (Late Jurassic). It has recently been postulated that an expanded Hadley cell, with an intensified but alternating hydrological cycle, heavily influenced sedimentation and total organic carbon (TOC) enrichment by promoting primary productivity and organic matter burial in the UK sectors of the Boreal Seaway. Consistent with such climate boundary conditions, petrographic observations, total organic carbon and carbonate contents, and major and trace element data presented here indicate that the KCF of the Cleveland Basin was deposited in the Laurasian Seaway under the influence of these conditions.

Depositional conditions alternated between three states that produced a distinct cyclicity in the lithological and geochemical records: lower-variability mudstone intervals (LVMIs) which comprise clay-rich mudstone and higher-variability mudstone intervals (HVMIs) which comprise TOC-rich sedimentation and carbonate-rich sedimentation. The lower-variability mudstone intervals dominate the studied interval but are punctuated by three  2–4 m thick intervals of alternating TOC-rich and carbonate-rich sedimentation (HVMIs). During the lower-variability mudstone intervals, conditions were quiescent with oxic to suboxic bottom water conditions. During the higher-variability mudstone intervals, highly dynamic conditions resulted in repeated switching of the redox system in a way similar to the modern deep basins of the Baltic Sea. During carbonate-rich sedimentation, oxic conditions prevailed, most likely due to elevated depositional energies at the seafloor by current–wave action. During TOC-rich sedimentation, intermittent anoxic–euxinic conditions led to an enrichment of redox-sensitive and sulfide-forming trace metals at the seafloor and a preservation of organic matter, and an active Mn–Fe particulate shuttle delivered redox-sensitive and sulfide-forming trace metals to the seafloor. In addition, based on TOC–S–Fe relationships, organic matter sulfurization appears to have increased organic material preservation in about half of the analysed samples throughout the core, while the remaining samples were either dominated by excess Fe input into the system or experienced pyrite oxidation and sulfur loss during oxygenation events. New Hg∕TOC data do not provide evidence of increased volcanism during this time, consistent with previous work. Set in the context of recent climate modelling, our study provides a comprehensive example of the dynamic climate-driven depositional and redox conditions that can control TOC and metal accumulations in a shallow epicontinental sea, and it is therefore key to understanding the formation of similar deposits throughout Earth's history.

1 Introduction
Back to toptop

It is widely accepted that fine-grained marine sedimentary rocks preserve the most complete record of Earth's history (see Trabucho-Alexandre, 2015, and references therein for a discussion). As such, understanding their formation is fundamental to investigating changes in climate, weathering regime, biogeochemical cycles, sedimentation, land–ocean linkages, and environmental change throughout geological time. Organic-carbon-enriched mudstones are particularly pertinent to this as they represent dramatic perturbations in the carbon cycle and might therefore be of value in predicting future environmental dynamics. Such mudstones also represent some of the most important global energy resources: petroleum source rocks. Understanding their formation is therefore of economic as well as environmental and broader scientific interest.

The Phanerozoic sedimentary record is punctuated by several instances of increased organic carbon burial, for example the oceanic anoxic events during the early Toarcian, early Aptian, and early Albian (Jenkyns, 2010). The deposition of organic-carbon-rich mudstones results from an interplay between the production and preservation of organic material (e.g. Tyson, 2005) as well as the dilution of organic material by other sedimentary components (e.g. Sageman et al., 2003). Sediment source and supply, primary production, biogeochemical cycling, water column redox conditions, and ocean connectivity have major implications for the formation of organic-carbon-rich mudstones. However, the relative role of each of these processes is widely debated (Demaison and Moore, 1980; Pedersen and Calvert, 1990; Demaison et al., 1991; Tyson, 2001; Katz, 2005). The chemical makeup of a sedimentary succession can be used to assess these processes and reveal much about the depositional system, palaeoclimate, and basin history during deposition (e.g. Brumsack, 2006). When combined with petrographic observations, such analysis is a powerful tool with which environmental change can be determined over geological time.

A conceptual model developed for the Cretaceous (Hofmann and Wagner, 2011; Wagner et al., 2013) and further expanded to the Late Jurassic (Armstrong et al., 2016) linked the deposition of the TOC-rich Kimmeridge Clay Formation (KCF) to atmospheric dynamics, specifically the shift and expansion of the orbitally modulated subtropical–tropical Hadley cell, and associated changes in precipitation. Based on data from the type successions in Dorset, UK, Armstrong et al. (2016) proposed that organic-carbon-lean mudstones in the Kimmeridge Clay Formation were deposited during drier intervals characterized by mixed-layer oxygenated conditions, whereas organic-carbon-rich intervals were deposited under monsoonal conditions similar to those seen in the present-day tropics. During such intervals, enhanced freshwater and nutrient input from continental runoff produced stratified basins across the Boreal Seaway (Armstrong et al., 2016). The chronostratigraphic framework indicated that major fluctuations between wet and dry conditions occurred on a short eccentricity (100 kyr) timescale (Huang et al., 2010; Armstrong et al., 2016).

Here we present total organic carbon (TOC), total sulfur (TS), carbonate, major and trace element contents, and carbon isotope data, together with petrographic observations, for the Ebberston 87 Core (Fig. 1a) in order to investigate the primary controls on Late Jurassic sedimentation and TOC enrichment in the Cleveland Basin (Yorkshire, UK) and to further refine the hypotheses proposed by Armstrong et al. (2016).

Figure 1(a) Graphic log showing lithological variation of the studied section against geological time. See key for details. Horizontal arrows point to the petrographic study sample positions. Organic-rich bands (ORBs) 4 and 5 as defined by Gallois (1979). Astrochronology after Huang et al. (2010) and Armstrong et al. (2016). (b) Palaeogeographical map (modified from Turner et al., 2019). (c) Modern-day geological map of the Cleveland Basin (after Powell, 2010). Red dots mark the location of the Marton 87, Ebberston 87, Flixton 87, and Reighton 87 boreholes.

2 Geological setting
Back to toptop

Deposited during the Kimmeridgian and Tithonian stages of the Late Jurassic, the Kimmeridge Clay Formation (KCF) is up to 620 m thick and is biostratigraphically and geochemically correlated across northwest Europe. In the Late Jurassic, atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations were more than 4 times greater than those of the present day (Sellwood and Valdes, 2008). Much of northwest Europe was submerged by a shallow epicontinental sea, the Laurasian Seaway. The Laurasian Seaway comprised a series of interconnected basins, one of which was the Cleveland Basin, formed as a result of differential subsidence that started in the Triassic and continued through the Jurassic and Cretaceous (Rawson et al., 2000). The seaway connected the Boreal Sea to the Tethys Ocean through the Viking Corridor, situated between  35 and  40 N palaeolatitude (Korte et al., 2015) (Fig. 1b).

Recent palaeoclimate modelling, paired with geochemistry and sedimentology from the Dorset and Yorkshire basins, indicates that the Laurasian Seaway was affected by a hot, humid climate comparable to present-day tropical monsoon regions (Armstrong et al., 2016). Deposition under these conditions was posited to have been strongly influenced by an intensified hydrological cycle and associated storm events. This would have promoted organic carbon enrichment through enhanced primary productivity from increased precipitation and continental runoff-driven nutrient supply, ocean overturn, and enhanced OM preservation from salinity–temperature stratification and a reduction in bottom water ventilation. However, water depth reconstructions for the Laurasian Seaway are contentious and depend upon the preferred depositional model (Bradshaw et al., 1992). A water depth of tens of metres has been proposed by some authors (e.g. Hallam, 1975; Aigner, 1980; Oschmann, 1988), while others (e.g. Gallois, 1976; Haq et al., 1988; Herbin et al., 1991) have suggested a major Late Jurassic transgression that led to water depths of hundreds of metres. Reconstructions of sea-level change do not correlate with cycles in organic matter content, indicating that sea level is not a primary control on organic matter enrichment (Herbin et al., 1993; Williams et al., 2001).

The KCF type section is exceptionally well-exposed along the coast around Kimmeridge Bay (Dorset, UK; Fig. 1b) and was cored as part of a high-resolution analysis project (see, e.g. Morgans-Bell et al., 2001). It has been extensively studied by sedimentologists (Macquaker and Gawthorpe, 1993; Macquaker et al., 2010), stratigraphers (Morgans-Bell et al., 2001), palaeontologists (Lees et al., 2004), geochemists (Pearce et al., 2010), and palaeoclimatologists (Hesselbo et al., 2009) all trying to unravel the processes responsible for its deposition.

Owing to a lack of coastal outcrops, however, the study of laterally equivalent deposits in the Cleveland Basin (Yorkshire, UK) has been limited to four cores drilled in the 1980s (Herbin et al., 1991, 1993; Herbin and Geyssant, 1993; Tribovillard et al., 1994; Boussafir et al., 1995; Herbin et al., 1995; Boussafir and Lallier-Vergès, 1997; Lallier-Vergès et al., 1997; Tribovillard et al., 2004). These four cores (Marton 87, Flixton 87, Ebberston 87, and Reighton 87; Fig. 1c) have been correlated with the type section in Dorset using the so-called “organic-rich bands” (ORBs) (see Fig. 6 in Armstrong et al., 2016) defined by Gallois (1979) and later referred to by Herbin and Geyssant (1993).

The focus of the present study is the Ebberston 87 Core (541247.7′′ N, 03722.7′′ W), which is thermally immature (average Tmax=425C; Herbin et al., 1993) and contains type II and III kerogens (Herbin et al., 1993; Scotchman, 1991). The interval of detailed analysis spans the Pectinatites wheatleyensis to Pectinatites pectinatus ammonite biozones and is equivalent to ORBs 4 and 5 of Herbin and Geyssant (1993) (Fig. 1a).

3 Materials and methods
Back to toptop

A total of 116 samples were collected from the Ebberston 87 Core stored in the IFP Energies Nouvelles (IFPEN) facilities (Chartres, France). Samples of 1 cm thickness were collected at 50 cm intervals through a 40 m thick section of the core. Sampling resolution was increased to 10 cm in darker, more organic-carbon-rich intervals. Using established chronology of the Ebberston 87 Core (Herbin et al., 1993) and assuming a linear sedimentation rate, the studied interval spans approximately 800 kyr.

A total of 47 samples were prepared as thin sections and examined under optical light and a scanning electron microscope (SEM). Samples were divided into microlithofacies based on composition, texture, and bedding features, following the nomenclature guidelines set out by Lazar et al. (2015), whereby sand is defined as any grain between 62.5 and 2000 µm, coarse mud is between 62.5 and 32 µm, medium mud is between 32 and 8 µm, and fine mud is anything less than 8 µm. Grain size was measured using the rule in the SEM Aztec software.

Total organic carbon (TOC) and total carbon (TC) were measured by LECO combustion analysis at Newcastle University. Equivalent CaCO3 contents were calculated as CaCO3 = (TC TOC) × molar mass CaCO3 molar mass C = (TC TOC) × 8.33. Wavelength-dispersive X-ray fluorescence (XRF) analyses were conducted at the Institute for Chemistry and Biology of the Marine Environment (ICBM, University of Oldenburg) to determine the major (Si, Ti, Al, and Fe) and trace (Mn, As, Co, Cr, Cu, Mo, V, U, Zn and Zr) element contents of all samples; 114 samples were decalcified with 5 % HCl to remove the carbonate and analysed for δ13Corg values (calculated to the VPDB standard) using a Costech ECS4010 elemental analyser connected to a VG TripleTrap and Optima dual-inlet mass spectrometer using within-run laboratory standards calibrated against NBS18, NBS19, and NBS22 at the BGS stable isotope facility (part of the National Environmental Isotope Facility). A precision of ±< 0.1 ‰ (1 SD) was recorded; 49 samples were analysed for select trace elements (Mo, Cd, U, V, Re, Tl, As, and Sb) and Hg contents by quadrupole inductively coupled plasma–mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and a direct mercury analyser (DMA80, Milestone), respectively, at the Leibniz Institute for Baltic Sea Research (IOW). Total sulfur contents were measured on the same 49 samples using a LECO CS230 carbon–sulfur analyser at Newcastle University. Sediments from the Landsort Deep (Baltic Sea) were analysed for Al and the above-mentioned trace metals by inductively coupled plasma–optical emission spectrometry and ICP-MS, respectively (major and trace elements: wt %, ppm, and ppb, as appropriate). See the Supplement for details on sample preparation and analytical procedures.

Major and trace element contents were normalized to Al to allow for the assessment of relative changes irrespective of dilution by organic matter or carbonate. Aluminium was chosen as representative of the siliciclastic fine-grained sediment fraction due to its generally high contents in the samples and its limited involvement in biological, redox, and diagenetic processes (Tribovillard et al., 2006; element  Al ratios: expressed as wt %  wt %, ppm  wt %, or ppb  % as appropriate). Trace element enrichment factors (EFs; Brumsack, 2006) were calculated relative to the element  Al ratio of upper continental crust (UCC; Rudnick and Gao, 2003.).

Linear sedimentation rates (LSRs) were calculated for the P. wheatleyensis, P. hudlestoni, and P. pectinatus biozones using ammonite zonal boundary dates in the Geologic Timescale (Gradstein et al., 2012).

4 Results
Back to toptop

Based on integrated geochemical data and petrographic observations, the studied section is divided into four lower-variability mudstone intervals (LVMIs) and three distinct higher-variability mudstone intervals (HVMIs) at 37–40, 45–47, and 65–69 m of core depth (Fig. 2). The HVMIs are defined by distinct alternating facies along with repeated extreme enrichments of total organic carbon contents and trace elements, as shown in Fig. 2. The P. wheatleyensis, P. hudlestoni, and P. pectinatus zones have LSRs of 6.6, 5.1, and 4.1 cm kyr−1, respectively.

Figure 2Graphic log showing lithological variation of the studied section. Depth plots of total organic carbon (TOC) contents (wt %), calcium carbonate (CaCO3) contents (wt %), and organic carbon isotope values (‰ VPDB). Grey panels depict the higher-variability intervals (HVMIs) defined in this study. Black horizontal arrows indicate samples with obvious diagenetic overprint.


4.1 Petrographic characterization

We defined six lithofacies based on compositional and textural observations (Fig. 3): (1) clastic detritus-rich medium-grained mudstone, (2) organic material and calcareous pellet-rich laminated medium to coarse mudstone, (3) coccolith-dominated medium mudstone, (4) agglutinated foraminifera-bearing, medium to coarse carbonaceous mudstone, (5) biogenic-detritus-dominated fine to medium mudstone, and (6) carbonate-cemented coarse mudstone. The lower-variability mudstone intervals are comprised of facies 1, 5, and 6, while the higher-variability mudstone intervals are dominated by facies 2, 3, and 4.

Figure 3Summary table describing the six lithofacies identified in the petrographic study. Key descriptions and interpretations are noted for each facies along with a representative micrograph. All images are under plain polarized light. For further description, see the text.


4.1.1 Lower-variability mudstone interval (LVMI) petrography

Facies 1 comprises an argillaceous matrix containing medium to coarse mud-sized grains (Fig. 3). The coarsest grain fraction is fine to coarse mud-sized, unrounded quartz grains, occasional medium mud-sized chlorite grains, fine mud-sized titanium oxide grains, and very occasional phosphatic clasts. Equant pieces of organic matter (2–5 µm in diameter) and framboidal pyrite are finely disseminated throughout the matrix. Occasional organo-mineralic aggregates, comprised of wispy orange organic material (OM) and clay material, are found within the matrix. Calcitic microfossils, predominantly foraminifera tests and disarticulated shell fragments, are present and commonly infilled with authigenic kaolinite. These mudstones have a churned texture so most of the primary sedimentary structures have been destroyed; however, some samples contain infilled burrows, indicating the sediment was bioturbated (Fig. 4a). Physical mixing processes, indicated by occasional erosional surfaces, probably contributed to the homogenization of the sediment (Fig. 4b).

Figure 4(a) Photomicrograph showing a bioturbated sample (lighter patches are burrows). (b) Optical micrograph of an erosional base. (c) Optical micrograph showing faecal pellets (fp) and algal mats (yellow arrows). (d) Same sample as in (c). Scanning electron micrograph showing faecal pellets (fp) and algal mats (yellow arrows). (e) Agglutinated foraminifera with pyrite (py) both as framboids and as a replacement mineral. (f) Scanning electron micrograph showing a calcitic test infilled with authigenic kaolinite (ka) and pyrite (py).


Facies 4 is very similar to facies 1 but contains sand-sized quartz and is dominated by disarticulated calcitic shells, some of which are wholly or partially replaced by pyrite (Fig. 3).

Facies 6 is a medium to coarse mud-sized, angular, diagenetic carbonate grain-dominated sedimentary rock with an argillaceous matrix. Carbonate grains are microcrystalline, zoned, non-ferroan calcite and non-ferroan dolomite crystals. Relicts of the primary matrix, comprised of coccolith debris, organic matter, illitic clay, and fine quartz grains, can be seen between the diagenetic components. The three samples representing this facies type (Fig. 2, three arrows in the CaCO3 plot) are not included in the palaeoenvironmental interpretation as their primary sedimentary and geochemical signature appears to be strongly overprinted by diagenesis.

4.1.2 Higher-variability mudstone interval (HVMI) petrography

Facies 2 comprises sub-millimetre length, discontinuous, wavy lamina organized into normally graded centimetre-scale beds with erosional bases. The facies is dominated by amorphous algal marine-derived organic material aligning with and wrapped around the other sedimentary components, including the clay matrix, quartz grains, microfossils, lithic clasts, coccoliths, and framboidal pyrite (Fig. 3). Algal macerals commonly exist within organo-mineralic aggregates, and extensive “network” structures that are 500 µm thick and up to 2 mm in length point towards algal mat deposition (Fig. 4c, d). Coccoliths commonly occur within faecal pellets but also in the matrix (yellow arrows in Fig. 4c, d).

Facies 3 comprises normally graded, sub-millimetre laminae with erosional bases. The predominant sedimentary components are coccolith-rich faecal pellets that range in size from 30 to 3000 µm, unlike facies 2 where type II OM is a main sedimentary component (Fig. 3). The matrix is predominately pristine coccoliths and coccospheres but also contains clay minerals, equant lumps of organic material, and wispy algal macerals, calcispheres, chlorite grains, coarse mud-sized sub-rounded quartz grains, pyrite framboids (Fig. 4e), euhedral pyrite crystals (Fig. 4e), and occasional agglutinated foraminifera (Fig. 3), some of which are infilled with authigenic kaolinite (Fig. 4f).

Facies 5 is similar to facies 2 in that it has a carbonaceous, calcareous, and argillaceous matrix with medium to coarse mud-size grains. However, abundant agglutinated foraminifera, composed of quartz grains, clay minerals, and pyrite crystals, are observed in this facies. It is homogenized due to a combination of extensive bioturbation indicated by burrows and physical mixing suggested by occasional relict lamina.

Figure 5Ternary diagram (Brumsack, 1989) displaying the relative contributions of clay (Al2O3), quartz (SiO2), and carbonate (CaO) within all samples. Lower-variability mudstone interval (LVMI) samples are indicated by green crosses, and higher-variability mudstone interval (HVMI) samples are marked by blue symbols; TOC-rich samples (TOC > 10 wt %) are indicated by blue circles, and TOC-lean samples (TOC < 10 wt %) are indicated by blue crosses. Axes are scaled to improve the display of the data. Average shale (Wedepohl, 1991), upper continental crust (UCC; Rudnick and Gao, 2003), k feldspar, and kaolinite are plotted for reference. The dashed line shows the average shale–carbonate mixing line.


4.2 Geochemistry

Figure 5 shows a ternary diagram with the main inorganic lithogenic components represented by key proxy elements (Brumsack, 1989): clay is denoted by Al2O3, quartz by SiO2, and carbonate by CaO. All samples fall on or very close to a mixing line between the calcium carbonate endmember and a quartz–clay mixture that is more clay rich than average shale (Wedepohl, 1971, 1991) but less clay rich than upper continental crust (Rudnick and Gao, 2003).

Across the studied core section, total organic carbon (TOC) contents range from 0.8 wt % to 21.8 wt % with a mean of 6.6 wt %. Total sulfur contents range from 0.19 wt % to 6.94 wt % across the section. Equivalent CaCO3 contents range between 0.5 wt % and 73.8 wt % with a mean value of 28.5 wt % (Fig. 2). The CaCO3 contents of three samples (51.0, 53.3, and 57.0; indicated by arrows in Fig. 2) are likely to be erroneous given the abundance of dolomite identified in the petrographic analysis (Fig. 3). Petrographic and geochemical characteristics indicate strong overprinting by later-stage diagenesis (facies 6; Fig. 3), so these samples are discounted from palaeoenvironmental interpretation.

4.2.1 Lower-variability mudstone interval (LVMI) geochemistry

The lower-variability mudstone intervals are characterized by TOC contents ranging from 0.8 wt % to 10.4 wt % (Fig. 2) with a mean of 4.0 wt %. δ13Corg ranges from −25.7 ‰ to −27.9 ‰ with a mean of −26.7 ‰ (Fig. 2).

Silicon and Al range between 6.1 wt % and 22.2 wt % and between 3.1 wt % and 10.4 wt %, respectively. The Al-normalized ratios of Si, Ti, and Zr (indicative of coarse grain sizes and/or heavy minerals; Dellwig et al., 2000) range from 2.0 to 2.6, 0.04 to 0.05, and 9.8 to 17.6, respectively (Fig. 6). All redox-sensitive and sulfide-forming trace metals (Mo, U, V, Re, Tl, As, Sb, Hg, Fe, and Mn, Fig. 7; Cu, Zn, and Cd, Fig. S2) are consistently lower in the LVMIs compared to the HVMIs. Enrichment factors (Fig. S4) calculated relative to UCC for Mo, Re, Tl, As, Sb, Hg, Cu, Zn, and Cd are generally around 1 for the LVMIs. Uranium and V are slightly greater than 1, indicating a slight enrichment relative to UCC.

4.2.2 Higher-variability mudstone interval (HVMI) geochemistry

In the three higher-variability mudstone intervals (HVMIs), TOC ranges from 2.8 wt % to 25.7 wt % with a mean of 11.7 wt %. Calcium carbonate contents range from 6.8 wt % to 88.3 wt % with a mean of 36.0 wt %. δ13Corg ranges from −27.0 ‰ to −21.8 ‰, and the average of −25.3 ‰ is higher than in the lower-variability mudstone intervals (Fig. 2).

The records of Si and Al exhibit larger ranges in the HVMIs than in the LVMIs and range from 1.9 wt % to 23.9 wt % and from 0.59 wt % to 10.3 wt %, respectively. The coarse grain size and heavy-mineral-bound elements are slightly higher than in the LVMIs. Si∕Al, Ti∕Al, and Zr∕Al range from 2.0 to 3.3, 0.04 to 0.06, and 10.6 to 26.7, respectively (Fig. 6). Silica is positively correlated with Al (R2=0.98), which suggests that the Si is strongly associated with the clay fraction rather than biogenic, volcanogenic, or diagenetic silica in the sediment, consistent with petrographic observations. We can therefore use Si∕Al in conjunction with Ti∕Al and Zr∕Al ratios as proxies for variations in grain size and thus depositional energy (Tribovillard et al., 2006). The grain size indicators presented here (Fig. 6) suggest the HVMIs are slightly coarser grained and more variable than the LVMIs. However, for samples with Al values close to 0, this could partly be an artefact of normalization to Al, as some values in the HVMIs are low in Al contents compared to the LVMIs, probably due to the increased dilution of background terrigenous input by organic material and biogenic carbonate (Fig. 6). Therefore, normalization to Al in these intervals may produce spuriously high grain size proxy results and should be regarded with caution (for a further discussion see Van der Weijden, 2002).

Figure 6Depth plots of Al and Si concentrations, element  aluminium ratios, and Hg∕TOC. Si (%), Al (%), Si∕Al (%  %), Ti∕Al (%  %), Zr∕Al (ppm  %), and Hg∕TOC (ppm  %). Grey panels depict the higher-variability mudstone intervals (HVMIs) defined in this study. Vertical dashed lines represent upper continental crust (UCC) reference ratios.


All redox-sensitive and sulfide-forming trace metals (Mo, U, V, Re, Tl, As, Sb, Hg, Fe, and Mn, Fig. 7; Cu, Zn, and Cd, Fig. S2) are variable and enriched relative to the LVMIs. Notably, Mn∕Al correlates with CaCO3 content for the HVMIs (Fig. S3). Enrichment factors (Fig. S4) calculated relative to UCC for Mo, U, V, Re, Tl, As, Sb, Cu, Zn, and Cd are variable but generally > 1 in the HVMIs, indicating their enrichment relative to UCC.

5 Discussion
Back to toptop

5.1 Productivity and organic matter composition

Biological components (coccolithophores, foraminiferans, and organic matter – OM) occur in differing proportions throughout the section (Figs. 2 and 3). Our petrographic observations (Figs. 3 and 4) and organic carbon isotope data (Fig. 2) indicate a mixed OM type II–III component, in agreement with the published RockEval data that determine a type II–III OM source (Herbin et al., 1993; Scotchman, 1991). Type II OM constitutes marine OM, such as algal macerals, and has a higher δ13Corg than type III OM, which is terrigenous (Leng and Lewis, 2017). Fluctuations in δ13Corg correspond to the changes in the dominant OM source (marine versus terrestrial) as demonstrated in the petrography; therefore, we use δ13Corg as a proxy for OM source.

5.1.1 Productivity and organic matter composition in the lower-variability mudstone intervals (LVMIs)

Type III OM, with typical carbon isotope values of −26 ‰ to −28 ‰ VPDB, is ubiquitous in the LVMIs (Figs. 2, 3, and 4). The OM was produced on adjacent landmasses and was transported into the marine environment along with other detrital components, such as quartz and clay minerals. The largely very fine-grained nature of the LVMIs suggests that organic material, together with clay-sized siliciclastic detritus, was preferentially deposited away from a major coarse-grained river system. Furthermore, type III organic material is more resistant to oxidative degradation and hydrodynamic disaggregation due to its structure and chemistry, which explains how organic material enrichment in the LVMIs (average TOC = 4.0 wt %) is possible in an environment that had an active benthic ecosystem indicative of oxic–suboxic bottom water conditions. In addition to abundant terrestrial organic material, there are occasional algal macerals in the LVMIs.

5.1.2 Productivity and organic matter composition in the higher-variability mudstone intervals

In contrast to the LVMIs, the TOC-rich intervals of the HVMIs (average TOC = 12.3 wt %) are dominated by type II OM. Wispy lamina, algal maceral material (Figs. 3 and 4), and algal mats are the main source of OM in these intervals, although type III OM remains ubiquitous and coincides with the occurrence of detrital material, i.e. quartz grains, lithic clasts, and clay minerals, in the samples. In the TOC-rich parts of the HVMIs, large amounts of type II algal-derived material deposited at the seafloor acted to dilute the detrital sediment and type III OM.

The occurrence of organo-mineralic aggregates and algal OM (20 µm thick and 200 µm long; Fig. 3) demonstrates marine snow and algal mat settling as key mechanisms for the delivery of OM to the seafloor (Macquaker et al., 2010). Filter-feeding organisms strip nutrients and fine-grained sediment out of the water column and excrete them as faecal pellets (Ittekkot et al., 1992). This biological mediation of the sediment is a key process in the export of OM, sediment, and nutrients from the water column to the sediment. Ittekkot et al. (1992) demonstrated a link between enhanced sediment and nutrient flux to the ocean during wet phases of the monsoonal cycle. They also showed that there was an increase in biotic–abiotic pellet production, and thus an enhanced OM and mineral flux to the seafloor, in response to enhanced continental runoff and weathering associated with monsoonal wet phases.

Production of algal macerals in the oceans is affected by the availability of light and nutrients (Pedersen and Calvert, 1990). Given the palaeolatitudinal positioning of the section (Fig. 1b) it is likely that light did not limit primary productivity. We therefore propose that nutrient availability was the driver of changes in productivity. Nutrients are supplied to the euphotic zone through continental weathering or upwelling–overturning of nutrient-rich waters. Given the palaeogeographic setting of the Cleveland Basin in an epicontinental seaway, it is likely that changes in precipitation on the surrounding landmasses were a key driver of changes in productivity. The wet–dry cycles proposed by recent climate modelling (Armstrong et al., 2016) may therefore be the key driver behind oscillations in the production and preservation of TOC, i.e. the switching between the LVMIs and HVMIs. Alternatively, the variations in TOC could result from variable dilution of the OM by carbonate or detrital material, or the variations could result from a combination of both dilution and wet–dry cycles.

Carbonate productivity, mainly in the form of coccoliths, varies throughout the studied KCF section and is at its maximum within the carbonate-rich sections of the HVMIs. High nutrient availability in the photic zone of the water column, indicated by high OM productivity, also influences the rate of carbonate productivity (Lees et al., 2006). Within the HVMIs, alternations between TOC-rich deposition likely occurred during high nutrient availability, and carbonate-rich deposition is more likely under less nutrient-rich conditions. This alternation may result from ecological switching driven by oceanographic or climate processes that subtly altered the nutrient levels during these intervals. The organization of the coccoliths into faecal pellets in both the TOC-rich and carbonate-rich intervals of the HVMIs indicates a high abundance of higher trophic organisms to graze on a plentiful supply of food, further supporting an elevated nutrient level during these intervals. Furthermore, faecal pellets reduce the time taken for sediment to reach the seafloor (e.g. Shanks, 2002), so the abundance of pellets and organo-mineralic aggregates led to increased OM export efficiency and thus enhanced OM preservation (Macquaker et al., 2010). For the Dorset section, Macquaker et al. (2010) suggested that zooplankton were the main grazers and producers of faecal pellets. Our petrographic study of the Ebberston 87 Core reveals strong similarities with the type section in Dorset, so we tentatively suggest that zooplankton were also the main grazers in the Cleveland Basin at the time of deposition. Alternatively, variations in carbonate may be as a result of dilution by other sedimentary components.

5.2 Depositional environment: sediment source, depositional energy, dispersal mechanisms, and climatic context

The studied succession is a three-component system comprising clay-dominated, organic-carbon-dominated, and carbonate-dominated facies (Fig. 3). The clay fraction of the mudstones is probably derived from detrital inputs to the basin through the weathering of nearby emergent landmasses. Possible sources include Cornubia or the Welsh, Irish, or London–Brabant landmasses (Fig. 1b), as discussed by Hesselbo et al. (2009). Terrestrial organic matter (OM) was likely washed into the basin along with detrital clays, while carbonate and marine OM formed in the water column.

On geological timescales, mercury is released in large volumes during volcanism (Percival et al., 2015). A relatively long atmospheric residence time (1–2 years) means it can be globally distributed prior to deposition in the sedimentary record. Mercury enters the ocean primarily through precipitation, and once in the ocean it is preferentially adsorbed onto organic matter. Assuming the Hg is adsorbed to the organic material, the assessment of Hg∕TOC ratios can indicate an increased–reduced supply of Hg in the system (Percival et al., 2015); hence, it can be utilized as a proxy for volcanism. However, caution must be taken when interpreting records of Hg enrichments in sedimentary rocks because Hg can accumulate as a result of several other processes (e.g. Them et al., 2019; Grasby et al., 2019). Diagenesis may affect Hg contents, depending upon which sedimentary component hosts the it (e.g. organic matter or pyrite), and ongoing research is still exploring this (Them et al., 2019). A volcanogenic sediment source is ruled out using Hg∕TOC as a proxy (Scaife et al., 2017) (Fig. 6), which agrees with other studies of the KCF (Percival et al., 2015), and petrographic evidence (conchoidally fractured quartz grains without Fe oxide rims) rules out an aeolian source, which is also supported by the palaeogeographical position of this basin in the outer palaeo-subtropics (Armstrong et al., 2016).

The SiO2, Al2O3, and CaCO3 ternary diagram (Fig. 5) suggests the studied mudstones have an overall finer grain size than average shale. This may result from either the presence of more clay material or a higher contribution of Al-rich clay minerals (e.g. kaolinite); however, petrographic results show a predominance of illite (K–Al-rich clay mineral) in the matrix, suggesting it is more clay rich than average shale, which corroborates published XRD analyses (Herbin et al., 1991). It is possible that either the coarse-grained siliciclastic fraction of the sediment was trapped in nearshore proximal settings, with only fine-grained material being transported to more distal settings within the Cleveland Basin, or that the fine-grained nature of the sediment may result from the weathering of fine-grained source material on the hinterland or the deposition of palimpsest sediment that was deposited and remobilized on the ocean. Nevertheless, linear sedimentation rates (LSRs) were calculated as 6.6, 5.1, and 4.1 cm kyr−1 for the P. wheatleyensis, P. hudlestoni, and P. pectinatus ammonite biozones, respectively, indicating that the system was not starved of sediment.

Depth plots of geochemical grain size proxies (Fig. 6) indicate generally quiescent conditions in the LVMIs, with slightly more variable energy in the HVMIs. Petrographic observations support the geochemical grain size proxies, showing a lower proportion of clay material and a dominance of alternating organic-carbon- and carbonate-rich sediment in the HVMIs (particularly in facies 2 and 3). In addition to the compositional variations, the occurrence of normally graded beds with erosional bases in TOC-rich sections of the HVMIs indicates an energetically dynamic setting. Occasional higher-energy conditions affected sediment deposition and dispersal at the seafloor and led to winnowing of the finest grain sizes. Significant quantities of terrestrial OM (identified by δ13Corg and petrography), coupled with its overall fine-grained nature, suggest that the sediments accumulated in a depositional setting where hydrodynamic processes sorted the sediment based on particle size and density.

Owing to the shallow gradients and vast extent of epicontinental seaways, sediment dispersal in the LVMIs, which are dominated by terrigenous mud, may have been controlled by wind- and tide-induced bottom currents (Schieber, 2016); however, uncertainty on water depths in the Cleveland Basin at the time of deposition means it is not possible to determine the significance of these processes.

The occurrence of faecal pellets, increases in grain size, TOC, and CaCO3 observed in the HVMIs studied here points towards enhanced productivity, which is likely to be a regional phenomenon. If this was not limited to the Cleveland Basin, it may explain a coeval organic enrichment across the Laurasian Seaway. The causal mechanism behind the increase in productivity cannot be constrained with the present dataset. However, slight increases in depositional energy may result from intermittent storm mixing or changes in bottom water currents, which could both increase primary productivity.

Armstrong et al. (2016) attributed alternations in TOC enrichment to orbitally forced changes in humidity–aridity occurring over a short eccentricity timescale (100 kyr). Based on the chronostratigraphic time frame for the Yorkshire and Dorset sections (Armstrong et al., 2016; Huang et al., 2010) and assuming a linear sedimentation rate, the changes between the HVMIs and LVMIs equate with short eccentricity cycles. Thus, our observations match the prediction of Armstrong et al. (2016) that enhanced TOC burial occurred during wet periods through enhanced continental weathering, nutrient supply to the ocean, and primary productivity. The astrochronological timescale established for the Swanworth Quarry 1 Core in the Wessex Basin (Huang et al., 2010) and applied to the Ebberston 87 Core in the Cleveland Basin (Armstrong et al., 2016) is plotted for reference in Fig. 1a. Given the relatively short duration of the studied interval, it is not possible to conduct further spectral analysis with the present dataset.

5.3 Redox conditions

5.3.1 Redox conditions in the lower-variability mudstone intervals (LVMIs)

In the lower-variability mudstone intervals, petrographic results demonstrate extensive bioturbation, most likely resulting from widespread faunal colonization of the sediment surface due to well-oxygenated bottom waters (Fig. 4). However, enrichment factors of redox-sensitive elements (Fig. 7) (Brumsack, 2006; Tribovillard et al., 2006; Piper and Calvert, 2009) indicate that during the deposition of the LVMIs, the sediment pore water was suboxic. This interpretation is further supported by the low Mn∕Al and high (TOC = 0.8–10.4 wt %; Fig. 2) TOC contents.

Figure 7Depth plots of elemental ratios used as palaeoredox indicators. Mo∕Al (ppm  wt %), U∕Al (ppm  wt %), V∕Al (ppm  wt %), Re∕Al (ppm  wt %), Tl∕Al (ppm  wt %), As∕Al (ppm  wt %), Sb∕Al (ppm  wt %), Hg∕Al ×102 (ppm  wt %), Fe∕Al (wt %  wt %), and Mn∕Al (ppm  wt %). Grey panels depict the higher-variability mudstone intervals (HVMIs) defined in this study. Where grey and black circles are seen on the same plot, grey circles mark the XRF data and black circles mark the ICP-MS data.


It is difficult to reconcile the high TOC contents, which are considered extremely TOC rich and qualify as a potential hydrocarbon source rock, with oxygenated bottom waters. We explain this apparent conundrum by the presence of terrestrial OM in the LVMIs as demonstrated by lower δ13Corg (Fig. 2), petrography (Fig. 3) from this study, and published RockEval data (Herbin et al., 1993). In comparison to its marine counterpart, terrestrial organic matter often has a higher preservation potential because its chemical structure can make it less susceptible to oxidative degradation and because sulfate-reducing bacteria have a lower affinity for terrestrial OM (Dellwig et al., 2001). Similarly, marine algal macerals have a greater chance of being preserved when incorporated into organo-mineralic aggregates that are observed in the HVMIs because physical and chemical attractions between the aggregate components form a protective barrier to oxidants, thus reducing the oxidative destruction of algal macerals (Macquaker et al., 2010).

5.3.2 Redox conditions in the higher-variability mudstone intervals (HVMIs)

The TOC-rich parts of the HVMIs are dominated by algal macerals (Figs. 3 and 4), which account for the elevated TOC concentrations of up to 25.7 wt % (Fig. 2). Enrichments in redox-sensitive and sulfide-forming elements (Mo, U, V, Zn, Cd, Re, As, Sb, Hg, and Fe, Fig. 7; Zn and Cd, Fig. S2) clearly support the notion of periodically anoxic to euxinic pore and bottom waters at the study site (Brumsack, 2006; Tribovillard et al., 2006), which enhanced the preservation of OM during these intervals. However, the presence of agglutinated foraminifera within the TOC-rich parts of the HVMIs, as well as enrichments of Mn relative to the LVMIs (Fig. 7), indicates that oxygen must have been present at the seafloor, at least episodically (Dellwig et al., 2018; Macquaker et al., 2010). A positive correlation between Mn∕Al and CaCO3 in the HVMIs (Fig. S3) is further evidence that during favourable conditions for CaCO3 formation, Mn was sequestered into the sediment, thus implying repeated oxygenation events (see Herndon et al., 2018, for an alternative discussion). Nevertheless, this scenario has similarities to the modern Baltic Sea deeps (Landsort Deep, Gotland Basin) that display dramatic shifts between euxinic conditions during stagnation and oxic conditions during North Sea water incursions, leading to the sequestration of large amounts of Mn carbonate into the sediments (Dellwig et al., 2018; Häusler et al., 2018; Scholz et al., 2018).

Figure 8(a) Depth plot for Mo∕U (ppm  ppm) (after Algeo and Tribovillard, 2009). Grey panels depict the higher-variability mudstone intervals (HVMIs) defined in this study; (b) scatter plot of Mo EF versus U EF calculated relative to Post-Archean Average Shale (PAAS; Taylor and McLennan, 1985; after Tribovillard et al., 2012). Lower-variability mudstone interval (LVMI) samples are indicated by blue circles, and HVMIs are indicated by green squares. Data from the Ebberston 87 Core by Tribovillard et al. (2004) are represented by orange squares. Dashed lines are modern-day seawater; 0.3× modern-day seawater and 0.1× modern-day seawater values are shown for reference. The particulate shuttle is mapped in blue, and the unrestricted marine setting is mapped in pink. Axes are logarithmic.


5.3.3 Fe enrichment and sulfide formation

The significant enrichments of Fe in the TOC-rich intervals of the HVMIs are related to microbial sulfate reduction and pyrite formation, following dissolution of Fe (oxyhydr)oxides at the seafloor. The formation of pyrite (FeS2) depends on the redox conditions of the sediment pore and overlying water column, so it can be used to reconstruct palaeoenvironmental conditions beyond the redox state (Hetzel et al., 2011). Figure 8 shows a Fex–TOC–S ternary diagram for the studied interval. Reactive iron is calculated as Fex= Fe  0.25 × Al to account for the fraction of Fe that is bound in the silicate fraction and unavailable for redox reactions (Brumsack, 1988; Dellwig et al., 1999). A fully quantified measurement of reactive iron in a sample must be determined experimentally; owing to the absence of this, we discuss samples only in a relative way. For the samples plotting above the TOC–pyrite mixing line, pyrite formation was limited by the availability of sulfur (in the form of H2S generated by bacterial sulfate reduction) and excess, less-pyritized reactive iron was preserved in the sediments (potentially as oxides or carbonates). Both in the LVMIs and the HVMIs, there are samples with an excess of reactive Fe relative to S. Limited availability of reactive OM to support bacterial sulfate reduction (i.e. limited H2S generation) may be the reason for the observed excess iron. Alternatively, it might be related to either the reoxidation of pyrite during oxygenation events (removing S but not Fe from the sediment) or a strong input of Fe into the system via a particulate shuttle mechanism (discussed in Sect. 5.3.4).

The samples that plot near the TOC–pyrite mixing line in Fig. 8 are assumed to represent an availability of reactive Fe and S in the system that matches the stoichiometry of pyrite; hence, they have a higher degree of pyritization. Pyritization explains the enrichment of metals known to accumulate with pyrite (e.g. As, Sb, and Mo; Tribovillard et al., 2004). In samples that plot below the TOC–pyrite mixing line in Fig. 8, pyrite formation is limited by the availability of reactive iron, meaning the degree of pyritization was high but there was also an excess of sulfide available in the system. Under these conditions, sulfide was able to react with OM through sulfurization (or natural vulcanization). Our results are consistent with Tribovillard et al. (2004), who concluded that pyrite formation prior to OM sulfurization may increase the sequestration of Mo into the sediment. This highlights the need for caution when using Mo as a single diagnostic proxy in palaeoenvironmental reconstruction. Tribovillard et al. (2004) further demonstrated a linear relationship between the quantity of “orange algal macerals” and Mo concentrations in the Ebberston 87 Core, supporting the presence of sulfurized OM. The resulting sulfurized OM is less vulnerable to oxidative degradation and thus has a greater preservation potential during burial. We suggest that this mechanism is partly the reason we observe high TOC contents in intervals that first underwent sustained periods of pore or bottom water euxinia and later periods of reoxygenation. Studies of Jurassic sediments of the Marton 87 Core (Fig. 1c), drilled 4 km away from the Ebberston 87 Core, by Boussafir et al. (1995) and Lallier-Vergès et al. (1997) also conclude that the sulfurization and/or natural vulcanization of type II OM enhanced the organic material preservation potential.

5.3.4 Evidence for a Fe–Mn shuttle and ocean restriction

In the context of pyrite formation versus OM sulfurization and the enrichment of trace metals at the seafloor, the delivery of Fe and Mn (oxyhydr)oxides via a so-called particulate shuttle may play an important role. The particulate shuttle effect describes the cycling of Mn and Fe through the redoxcline, which is an ocean layer characterized by steep geochemical gradients that are driven by changes and the point at which the solubility of certain mineral phases increases or diminishes, in particular Mn, Fe, and P phases (Dellwig et al., 2010). Dissolved Mn2+ diffuses from anoxic waters beneath the redoxcline to the oxygenated surface layer in which is it oxidized to form MnO2 particles. These particles react with Fe2+ to form mixed Mn∕Fe (oxyhydr)oxide particulates, which are highly efficient adsorbents of dissolved trace metals in the ocean (Goldberg, 1954). If these particulates sink and reach deeper sulfidic waters, the (oxyhydr)oxides are reduced, and Mn2+ diffuses back into the overlying waters, while Fe2+ reacts with H2S to form Fe sulfides that incorporate part of the released trace metals (Canfield et al., 1992; Huckriede and Meischner, 1996; Neretin et al., 2004; Dellwig et al., 2010; Tribovillard et al., 2015). This particulate shuttle plays a key role in the transfer of trace elements from the water column to the sediment (Goldberg, 1954; Tribovillard et al., 2015) and is particularly effective when redox conditions fluctuate (Algeo and Tribovillard, 2009). Of particular relevance to this study is the transfer of Mo, As, and Sb to the sediment, elements that Tribovillard et al. (2015) used as proxies for the presence of a Mn–Fe shuttle in ancient anoxic–euxinic ocean basins. In the present study, Fe∕Al (Fig. 7) and Mo∕U (Fig. 9a) co-variations point towards a Mn–Fe shuttle operating during deposition of TOC-rich sediment in the HVMIs. Manganese is repeatedly reduced and reoxidized through the shuttle and does not get removed into the sediments as long as bottom water conditions are suboxic, leading to a build-up of dissolved Mn in the water column. Therefore, the Mn contents encountered in the oxic layers are easily accounted for due to fast deposition of Mn oxide from the water column and subsequent transformation into Mn carbonates within the sediments. Peaks in Fe∕Al coincide with peaks in pyrite-associated trace metals (As∕Al, Sb∕Al; Fig. 7) and increased abundance of pyrite in thin sections (Fig. 3). We propose that a suboxic shuttle that remobilized Fe from shelf sediments (Wijsman et al., 2001; Severmann et al., 2008; Dellwig et al., 2010; Eckert et al., 2013) was active during deposition of the TOC-rich parts of the HVMIs in the Ebberston 87 Core and enriched reactive Fe in the sediments to levels significantly above UCC. Episodically high inputs of reactive Fe via a suboxic shuttle also prevented the accumulation of H2S in the pore waters, thereby limiting OM sulfurization. During ventilation events (as suggested by benthic foraminifera and Mn enrichments), some of the pyrite was reoxidized, and sulfate diffused from the pore water to the water column, while reactive Fe was retained in the sediment by precipitation of Fe (oxyhydr)oxides. Thus, samples that appear to be deposited under S-limited conditions in Fig. 8 may still contain organic sulfur. We conclude that the hyper-accumulation of TOC in this setting was controlled by high primary productivity, increased OM production, the balance of H2S generation, and the supply of reactive Fe via a suboxic shuttle.

Figure 9Fex–TOC–S ternary diagram (after Dellwig et al., 1999; Hetzel et al., 2011). See the text for comments on Fex calculation. The dashed line represents the TOC–pyrite mixing line. Lower-variability mudstone interval (LVMI) samples are indicated by green crosses (the three samples nearest to the Fex corner represent the diagenetically overprinted samples that were excluded from the interpretation). Higher-variability mudstone interval (HVMI) samples are marked by blue symbols, TOC-rich samples (TOC > 10 wt %) are indicated by blue circles, and TOC-lean samples (TOC < 10 wt %) are indicated by blue crosses.


In the context of developing an anoxic–euxinic water column in the Cleveland Basin, not only primary productivity but also basin restriction has to be considered as a contributing factor. Due to the specific biogeochemical behaviour of Mo, Mo∕U enrichment factors have been shown to give insights into the degree of restriction of a basin with examples from the Carico Basin, the Black Sea, the Late Pennsylvanian Midcontinent Sea, and the Late Devonian Seaway (Algeo and Tribovillard, 2009). Both elements tend to be enriched in sediments deposited under oxygen-depleted bottom water conditions but to varying degrees (Helz et al., 1996). Under suboxic conditions, U enrichment is likely to exceed Mo enrichment owing to the trapping of U at the Fe(II)∕Fe(III) redox boundary (Algeo and Tribovillard, 2009). As oxygenation of the water mass decreases further and sulfidic conditions develop in pore and bottom waters, Mo enrichment increases relative to that of U, and the Mo∕U ratio approaches or surpasses that of seawater due to the presence of sufficient H2S to convert the conservative molybdate ion to the highly particle-reactive thiomolybdate (Algeo and Tribovillard, 2009; Erickson and Helz, 2000). Mo∕U ratios for the LVMIs in this study are similar to that of average shale (Fig. 9a), pointing towards a detrital, rather than an authigenic, source of the Mo and U in these samples. Therefore, these samples cannot be used to investigate the presence of a Mn–Fe shuttle. In contrast, the HVMIs display repeated peaks in the Mo∕U ratio, indicative of strong Mo enrichments under euxinic conditions, facilitated by the activity of a Mn–Fe shuttle preferentially transferring Mo from the water column to the sediment (Algeo and Tribovillard, 2009).

Figure 10Bar chart illustrating enrichment factors (EFs) for Mn, As, Cd, Co, Mo, Ni, Re, Sb, U, V, and Zn relative to average shale (Wedepohl, 1991) for the Mediterranean sapropels, Black Sea Units 1 and 2, C/T Demerara Rise, Gulf of California, Peru margin (Brumsack, 2006), Baltic Sea, and higher-variability mudstone intervals (HVMIs) from the present study. Maximum EFs in this study are marked by black lines.


We compare our new results with existing data from Tribovillard et al. (2004), who analysed trace elements (Fig. 9b) in several samples from the Ebberston 87 Core, with cycle 3 in their study being equivalent to the stratigraphically oldest (Pectinatites wheatleyensis) HVMI in our study. The authors concluded that TOC enrichment in the Cleveland Basin occurred during times of transgression due to siliciclastic sediment starvation, high primary productivity, and water column stratification. Our higher-resolution sampled data agree with this conclusion in that on a Mo–U enrichment factor plot (Fig. 9b), the TOC-rich intervals plot clearly within the particulate shuttle field. Samples from the LVMIs plot outside this field, which confirms that during deposition of these samples the suboxic conditions were limited to the sediment. Pearce et al. (2010) concluded that the deposition of the KCF occurred in an unrestricted basin. Tribovillard et al. (2012) compared their results to those presented by Pearce et al. (2010) and agreed that is it unlikely that the Cleveland and Wessex basins were restricted for a prolonged period, if at all. In combination with our geochemical and petrographic data, we can confirm that the repeated development of anoxic–euxinic conditions in the Cleveland Basin was most likely due to high primary productivity, and possibly salinity stratification due to high amounts of freshwater runoff, but it is unlikely that the Cleveland Basin experienced prolonged restriction.

5.3.5 Comparison to modern organic-carbon-rich sediments

Comparing our data with those from different TOC-rich deposits enables us to better understand common processes involved in TOC enrichment in different palaeoenvironmental–depositional settings and draw wider conclusions for the present study. Figure 10 shows average enrichment factors (calculated with respect to average shale for select trace metals, Mn, As, Cd, Co, Cu, Mo, Re, Sb, U, V, and Zn, to facilitate direct comparison with the data in Brumsack, 2006) for the carbonate-rich and TOC-rich sections of the HVMIs in the present study and other well-studied deposits. Depositional environments, in which TOC and trace elements are enriched, can fall on a scale between two endmembers: coastal upwelling systems (e.g. Gulf of California, Peru coastal margin) and anoxic-basin type settings (e.g. the Mediterranean sapropels, Black Sea, Baltic Sea deeps). The former are characterized by seasonally high primary productivity and extensive oxygen minimum zones (OMZs) that are fuelled by wind-driven upwelling of high nutrient and trace metal waters, while the latter are characterized by permanent salinity stratification and water mass restriction (Brumsack, 2006).

The HVMIs in the present study bear similarities to the Gulf of California in that they exhibit similarities in Cd enrichment and depleted Mn in comparison to the HVMIs, indicating high productivity and suboxic conditions in the water column (Sweere et al., 2016). Cd enrichments suggest that parts of the HVMIs experienced upwelling-like processes, which may have resulted in high productivity. However, sulfidic conditions in the water column are rarely observed in upwelling settings (Brumsack, 2006); this differs from the studied Cleveland Basin and is reflected in the sulfide indicators (As and Mo; Fig. 7). This indicates that the method of trace metal sequestration is different in modern upwelling settings and the studied section, meaning they are a poor analogue for the present study.

Figure 11Schematic diagram illustrating depositional conditions during the different intervals of sedimentation. (a) Lower-variability mudstone interval, (b) periods of carbonate-rich sedimentation in the higher-variability mudstone intervals, and (c) periods of organic-carbon-rich sedimentation during the higher-variability mudstone intervals. The scale bar represents bathymetric lows, generally considered to be tens to hundreds of kilometres across.


The anoxic-basin type settings exhibit strong enrichments in sulfide-forming trace metals (Brumsack, 2006). However, the enrichment factors for the Mediterranean sapropels and Units 1 and 2 from the Black Sea exhibit different patterns (Fig. 10) owing to the pronounced depletion of trace elements in the water column of the Black Sea during Unit 1 and less pronounced euxinia during most parts of Unit 2 (Wegwerth et al., 2018). The studied HVMIs are most similar to Black Sea Unit 2 in that redox-sensitive (As, Cu, Mo, Re, U, V, and Zn) and productivity (Cd) elements are of the same order of magnitude. From this, we may infer similarities operating in Black Sea Unit 2 and the HVMIs. However, the modern Black Sea is permanently stratified and is governed by its unique hydrological setting. This is in stark contrast to the HVMIs in the Cleveland Basin, which exhibit rapid oscillations and were deposited in a shallow epicontinental seaway. It may be that the Late Jurassic Laurasian Seaway fluctuated between a setting close to an anoxic-basin type setting and a setting more analogous to a coastal upwelling zone.

5.3.6 Evidence for Baltic Sea characteristics

While the studied interval shares similarities and differences with both upwelling and anoxic-basin type settings, we are still lacking an appropriate modern analogue. Palaeogeography exerts a fundamental control on sedimentation, in particular TOC enrichment, but there is no modern-day example of a shallow epicontinental seaway. See Algeo et al. (2008) for a discussion of possible analogues. The Baltic Sea comprises a series of small basins that are interconnected by narrow sills and channels and bears resemblance to the Late Jurassic Laurasian Seaway. We propose that redox dynamics in the Cleveland Basin during the Late Jurassic shared similarities to those in the modern-day Baltic Sea in that they both fluctuated between LVMI and HVMI deposition. The enrichment factors in Fig. 10 are averaged across the HVMIs, indicating Mn depletion across these zones. However, there are several samples that are enriched in Mn within the HVMIs (Fig. 7), which points towards prolonged reoxygenation events during episodes of organic enrichment in the Kimmeridge Clay Formation.

The Baltic Sea receives saline water input from the North Sea and fresh water from riverine input, resulting in permanent stratification of the water column (Dellwig et al., 2018; Häusler et al., 2018). Coupled restriction of water mass exchange in the deeper sub-basins of the Baltic Sea leads to the appearance of water column anoxia–euxinia. However, large (and infrequent) inputs of saline and oxic water from the North Sea promote overturning and reoxygenation of the Baltic Sea deeps, causing extensive Mn carbonate formation in the sediments (Dellwig et al., 2018; Häusler et al., 2018). While the detailed mechanisms of Mn carbonate formation are still debated, the Mn carbonate deposits are generally associated with intervals of prolonged reoxygenation (e.g. in the Baltic Sea, plotted on Fig. 10) (Häusler et al., 2018) and most likely benefit from microbial mediation (Henkel et al., 2019). The Baltic Sea deeps represent an extreme example of Mn shuttling, whereby Mo is highly enriched as it is adsorbed to Mn, but U and Re are much less enriched. Enrichment factors calculated relative to average shale (Wedepohl, 1971, 1991) for the Landsort Deep in the Baltic Sea are plotted in Fig. 10. Data were generated from the 36GC-4 Core (see Häusler et al., 2017, 2018; Dellwig et al., 2019, for the Landsort Deep core and site description and age model) and are presented in the data repository.

6 Conclusions and conceptual model
Back to toptop

This study provides insight into the sedimentation in an epicontinental seaway during a greenhouse world. Examining sediment away from strong detrital dilution and overprint allows us to unpick the global controls on sedimentation and gives us further insight into the key processes in this palaeogeographic setting. Far away from detrital inputs, this location provides an excellent dataset for examining changes in water column processes.

The studied interval of the Kimmeridge Clay Formation in the Cleveland Basin was deposited in a highly dynamic environment that fluctuated from LVMI deposition to HVMIs (Fig. 11). During LVMI sedimentation (Fig. 11a), the water column was oxic and was able to sustain life to a degree that the sediment was extensively bioturbated. However, the sediment pore waters were suboxic, which facilitated the enrichment of TOC.

During each HVMI, the depositional environment experienced episodic and drastic changes. Trace element data indicate redox conditions of the bottom waters alternating between fully oxic and euxinic. During oxic conditions, organic matter (OM) and carbonate production proliferated (Fig. 10b, c). High primary productivity led to an increase in higher trophic feeders that produced masses of faecal pellets, in turn resulting in an increase in OM flux rate to the seafloor that aided the preservation of carbon and diluted the detrital material. At the same time, Mn and Fe (oxyhydr)oxides were deposited at the seafloor, together with adsorbed trace metals (Fig. 11b). Detrital element proxies indicate that the HVMIs, as a whole, have periodically higher depositional energies related to the LVMIs. The oxygenation events were most likely related to the downward supply of oxic water by either currents or waves.

Once these higher energetic conditions ended, the supply of oxygen to the seafloor could not keep up with the oxygen demand of organic matter degradation, and the deeper waters became anoxic–euxinic. During these intervals, sedimentation was predominated by algal macerals delivered to the sediment as organo-mineralic aggregates and marine snow under quiescent conditions. The production of sulfide minerals (e.g. pyrite) and the accumulation of related sulfide-forming trace metals was enhanced under these conditions, with the Fe being resupplied by a suboxic Fe shuttle that remobilized Fe through the chemocline. At times when Fe was not supplied, OM became sulfurized, which enhanced its preservation potential. Trace element enrichment was facilitated by a Mn∕Fe particulate shuttle.

We observe that the studied section bears similarity to the Landsort Deep of the present-day Baltic Sea in that a generally suboxic to euxinic system had periodic reoxygenation events.

In the context of the published chronostratigraphic framework, alternations between LVMIs and HVMIs occur on a short eccentricity (100 kyr) timescale. This is in line with the predictions presented by Armstrong et al. (2016), whereby an orbitally modulated expansion of the Late Jurassic Hadley cell led to alternations between humid and arid climate conditions. We propose that the highly dynamic conditions in the studied intervals are representative of wet and humid conditions during which changes in continental weathering enhanced primary productivity and led to TOC enrichment. Conversely, the LVMIs were deposited under arid conditions.

Data availability
Back to toptop
Data availability. 

Data is available in the PANGAEA data repository via: (Atar et al., 2019).

Back to toptop

The supplement related to this article is available online at:

Author contributions
Back to toptop
Author contributions. 

EA, CM, AA and TW were responsible for conceptualization, formal analysis, investigation, and methodology. In addition, CM, AA and TW also provided project supervision. OD, LH, VLV, ML and BS were responsible for investigation and methodology. All authors contributed to the writing and revision of this manuscript.

Competing interests
Back to toptop
Competing interests. 

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

Back to toptop

We thank staff at the Scottish Universities Environmental Research Centre for use of the facilities and help with sample preparation. Leon Bowen is thanked for training and support on the SEM. Phil Green, Alex Charlton, and David Earley are thanked for analytical assistance and training at Newcastle University. Howard Armstrong is acknowledged for assistance in sampling and discussions in the early stages of this project. Wagner Petrographic Ltd is acknowledged for the production of thin sections. We gratefully acknowledge the International Association of Sedimentologists for a postgraduate grant award used for the preparation of thin sections and NIGL for a grant-in-kind for the carbon isotope analyses. We thank Thomas Algeo and Jennifer McKay for constructive reviews that improved this paper.

Financial support
Back to toptop
Financial support. 

This publication contains work conducted during a PhD study undertaken as part of the Natural Environment Research Council (NERC) Centre for Doctoral Training (CDT) in Oil & Gas (grant number NEM00578X/1) and is fully funded by NERC, whose support is gratefully acknowledged.

Review statement
Back to toptop
Review statement. 

This paper was edited by Arne Winguth and reviewed by Jennifer McKay and Thomas Algeo.

Back to toptop

Aigner, T.: Biofabrics and stratinomy of the Lower Kimmeridge Clay (U. Jurassic, Dorset, England), Neues Jahrb. Geol. P.-A., 159, 324–338, 1980. 

Algeo, T. J. and Tribovillard, N.: Environmental analysis of paleoceanographic systems based on molybdenum–uranium covariation, Chem. Geol., 268, 211–225, 2009. 

Algeo, T. J., Heckel, P. H., Maynard, J. B, Blakey, R. C., Rowe, H., Pratt, B. R., and Holmden, C., Modern and ancient epeiric seas and the super-estuarine circulation model of marine anoxia, Dynamics of Epeiric Seas: Sedimentological, Paleontological and Geochemical Perspectives: Geological Association Canada Special Paper, 48, 7–38, 2008. 

Armstrong, H. A., Wagner, T., Herringshaw, L. G., Farnsworth, A. J., Lunt, D. J., Harland, M., Imber, J., Loptson, C., and Atar, E. F. L.: Hadley circulation and precipitation changes controlling black shale deposition in the Late Jurassic Boreal Seaway, Paleoceanography, 31, 1041–1053, 2016. 

Atar, E., März, C., Aplin, A. C., Dellwig, O., Herringshaw, L., Lamoureux-Var, V., Leng, M. J., Schnetger, B., and Wagner, T.: Geochemical data from the Ebberston 87 Core (Cleveland Basin, Yorkshire, UK), PANGAEA,, 2019. 

Boussafir, M. and Lallier-Vergès, E.: Accumulation of organic matter in the Kimmeridge Clay formation (KCF): an update fossilisation model for marine petroleum source-rocks, Mar. Petrol. Geol., 14, 75–83, 1997. 

Boussafir, M., Gelin, F., Lallier-Vergès, E., Derenne, S., Bertrand, P., and Largeau, C.: Electron microscopy and pyrolysis of kerogens from the Kimmeridge Clay Formation, UK: Source organisms, preservation processes, and origin of microcycles, Geochim. Cosmochim. Ac., 59, 3731–3747, 1995. 

Bradshaw, M. J., Cope, J. C. W., Cripps, D. W., Donovan, D. T., Howarth, M. K., Rawson, P. F., West, I. M., and Wimbledon, W. A.: Jurassic, Geological Society, London, Memoirs, 13, 107–129, 1992. 

Brumsack, H.-J.: Rezente, C-org-reiche Sedimente als Schlüssel zum Verständnis fossiler Schwarzschiefer, University of Göttingen, 1988. 

Brumsack, H.-J.: Geochemistry of recent TOC-rich sediments from the Gulf of California and the Black Sea, Geol. Rundsch., 78, 851–882, 1989. 

Brumsack, H.-J.: The trace metal content of recent organic carbon-rich sediments: Implications for Cretaceous black shale formation, Palaeogeogr. Palaeocl., 232, 344–361, 2006. 

Canfield, D. E., Raiswell, R., and Bottrell, S. H.: The reactivity of sedimentary iron minerals toward sulfide, Am. J. Sci., 292, 659–683, 1992. 

Dellwig, O., Watermann, F., Brumsack, H. J., and Gerdes, G.: High-resolution Reconstruction of a Holocene Coastal Sequence (NW Germany) Using Inorganic Geochemical Data and Diatom Inventories, Estuar. Coast. Shelf S., 48, 617–633, 1999. 

Dellwig, O., Hinrichs, J., Hild, A., and Brumsack, H. J.: Changing sedimentation in tidal flat sediments of the southern North Sea from the Holocene to the present: a geochemical approach, J. Sea Res., 44, 195–208, 2000. 

Dellwig, O., Watermann, F., Brumsack, H.-J., Gerdes, G., and Krumbein, W.: Sulphur and iron geochemistry of Holocene coastal peats (NW Germany): a tool for palaeoenvironmental reconstruction, Palaeogeogr. Palaeocl., 167, 359–379, 2001. 

Dellwig, O., Leipe, T., März, C., Glockzin, M., Pollehne, F., Schnetger, B., Yakushev, E. V., Böttcher, M. E., and Brumsack, H. J.: A new particulate Mn–Fe–P-shuttle at the redoxcline of anoxic basins, Geochim. Cosmochim. Ac., 74, 7100–7115, 2010. 

Dellwig, O., Schnetger, B., Meyer, D., Pollehne, F., Häusler, K., and Arz, H. W.: Impact of the Major Baltic Inflow in 2014 on Manganese Cycling in the Gotland Deep (Baltic Sea), Front. Mar. Sci., 5, 248,, 2018. 

Dellwig, O., Wegwerth, A., Schnetger, B., Schulz, H., and Arz, H. W.: Dissimilar behaviors of the geochemical twins W and Mo in hypoxic-euxinic marine basins, Earth-Sci. Rev., 193, 1–23, 2019. 

Demaison, G. J. and Moore, G. T.: Anoxic environments and oil source bed genesis, Org. Geochem., 2, 9–31, 1980. 

Demaison, G., Pedersen, T. F., and Calvert, S. E.: Anoxia vs. productivity; what controls the formation of organic-carbon-rich sediments and sedimentary rocks?; discussion and reply, AAPG Bull., 75, 499–501, 1991. 

Eckert, S., Brumsack, H.-J., Severmann, S., Schnetger, B., März, C., and Fröllje, H., Establishment of euxinic conditions in the Holocene Black Sea, Geology, 41, 431–434, 2013. 

Erickson, B. E. and Helz, G. R.: Molybdenum(VI) speciation in sulfidic waters: Stability and lability of thiomolybdates, Geochim. Cosmochim. Ac., 64, 1149–1158, 2000. 

Gallois, R. W.: Coccolith blooms in the Kimmeridge Clay and origin of North Sea Oil, Nature, 259, 473–475, 1976. 

Gallois, R. W.: Oil shale resources in Great Britain, Institute of Geological Sciences, London, 1979. 

Goldberg, E. D.: Marine geochemistry 1. Chemical scavengers of the sea, J. Geol., 62, 249–265, 1954. 

Gradstein, F. M., Ogg, J. G., Schmitz, M., and Ogg, G.: The geologic time scale 2012, Elsevier, Boston, 2012. 

Grasby, S. E., Them II, T. R., Chen, Z., Yin, R., and Ardakani, O. H.: Mercury as a proxy for volcanic emissions in the geologic record, Earth-Sci. Rev., 196, 102880,, 2019. 

Hallam, A.: Jurassic environments, Cambridge University Press, 1975. 

Haq, B. U., Hardenbol, J., and Vail, P. R.: Mesozoic and Cenozoic chronostratigraphy and cycles of sea-level change, in: Sea-Level Changes: An Integrated Approach, Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists, vol. 42,, 1988. 

Häusler, K., Moros, M., Wacker, L., Hammerschmidt, L., Dellwig, O., Leipe, T., Kotilainen, A., and Arz, H. W.: Mid- to late Holocene environmental separation of the northern and central Baltic Sea basins in response to differential land uplift, Boreas, 46, 111–128, 2017. 

Häusler, K., Dellwig, O., Schnetger, B., Feldens, P., Leipe, T., Moros, M., Pollehne, F., Schönke, M., Wegwerth, A., and Arz, H. W.: Massive Mn carbonate formation in the Landsort Deep (Baltic Sea): Hydrographic conditions, temporal succession, and Mn budget calculations, Mar. Geol., 395, 260–270, 2018. 

Helz, G. R., Miller, C. V., Charnock, J. M., Mosselmans, J. F. W., Pattrick, R. A. D., Garner, C. D., and Vaughan, D. J.: Mechanism of molybdenum removal from the sea and its concentration in black shales: EXAFS evidence, Geochim. Cosmochim. Ac., 60, 3631–3642, 1996. 

Henkel, J. V., Dellwig, O., Pollehne, F., Herlemann, D. P., Leipe, T., and Schulz-Vogt, H. N.: A bacterial isolate from the Black Sea oxidizes sulfide with manganese (IV) oxide, P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 116, 12153–12155, 2019. 

Herbin, J. P. and Geyssant, J. R.: Organic belts during Kimmeridgian/Tithonian in England (Yorkshire, Dorset) and France (Boulonnais), Cr. Acad. Sci. II, 317, 1309–1316, 1993. 

Herbin, J. P., Muller, C., Geyssant, J., Melieres, F., and Penn, I.: Heterogeneity of organic matter distribution in relation to a transgressive systems tract: Kimmeridge Clay (Jurassic), England, AAPG Bull., 75, 593–594, 1991. 

Herbin, J. P., Müller, C., Geyssant, J. R., Mélières, F., Penn, I. E., and Group, Y.: Variation of the distribution of organic matter within a transgressive system tract: Kimmeridge Clay (Jurassic), England, in: Source Rocks in a Sequence Stratigraphic Framework, American Association of Petroleum Geologists, 67–100, 1993. 

Herbin, J. P., Fernandez-Martinez, J. L., Geyssant, J. R., Albani, A. E., Deconinck, J. F., Proust, J. N., Colbeaux, J. P., and Vidier, J. P.: Sequence stratigraphy of source rocks applied to the study of the Kimmeridgian/Tithonian in the north-west European shelf (Dorset/UK, Yorkshire/UK and Boulonnais/France), Mar. Petrol. Geol., 12, 177–194, 1995. 

Herndon, E. M., Havig, J. R., Singer, D. M., McCormick, M. L., and Kump, L. R.: Manganese and iron geochemistry in sediments underlying the redox-stratified Fayetteville Green Lake, Geochim. Cosmochim. Ac., 231, 50–63, 2018. 

Hesselbo, S. P., Deconinck, J. F., Huggett, J. M., and Morgans Bell, H. S.: Late Jurassic palaeoclimatic change from clay mineralogy and gamma-ray spectrometry of the Kimmeridge Clay, Dorset, UK, J. Geol. Soc., 166, 1123–1133, 2009. 

Hetzel, A., März, C., Vogt, C., and Brumsack, H.-J.: Geochemical environment of Cenomanian – Turonian black shale deposition at Wunstorf (northern Germany), Cretaceous Res., 32, 480–494, 2011. 

Hofmann, P. and Wagner, T.: ITCZ controls on Late Cretaceous black shale sedimentation in the tropical Atlantic Ocean, Paleoceanography, 26, PA4223,, 2011. 

Huang, C., Hesselbo, S. P., and Hinnov, L.: Astrochronology of the late Jurassic Kimmeridge Clay (Dorset, England) and implications for Earth system processes, Earth Planet. Sc. Lett., 289, 242–255, 2010. 

Huckriede, H. and Meischner, D.: Origin and environment of manganese-rich sediments within black-shale basins, Geochim. Cosmochim. Ac., 60, 1399–1413, 1996. 

Ittekkot, V., Haake, B., Bartsch, M., Nair, R., and Ramaswamy, V.: Organic carbon removal in the sea: the continental connection, Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 64, 167–176, 1992 

Jenkyns, H. C.: Geochemistry of oceanic anoxic events, Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems, 11, Q03004,, 2010. 

Katz, B. J.: Controlling factors on source rock development – a review of productivity, preservation, and sedimentation rate, 2005. 

Korte, C., Hesselbo, S. P., Ullmann, C. V., Dietl, G., Ruhl, M., Schweigert, G., and Thibault, N.: Jurassic climate mode governed by ocean gateway, Nat. Commun., 6, 10015,, 2015. 

Lallier-Vergès, E., Hayes, J. M., Boussafir, M., Zaback, D. A., Tribovillard, N. P., Connan, J., and Bertrand, P.: Productivity-induced sulphur enrichment of hydrocarbon-rich sediments from the Kimmeridge Clay Formation, Chem. Geol., 134, 277–288, 1997. 

Lazar, O. R., Bohacs, K. M., Macquaker, J. H., Schieber, J., and Demko, T. M.: Capturing key attributes of fine-grained sedimentary rocks in outcrops, cores, and thin sections: nomenclature and description guidelines, J. Sediment. Res., 85, 230–246, 2015. 

Lees, J. A., Bown, P. R., Young, J. R., and Riding, J. B.: Evidence for annual records of phytoplankton productivity in the Kimmeridge Clay Formation coccolith stone bands (Upper Jurassic, Dorset, UK), Mar. Micropaleontol., 52, 29–49, 2004. 

Lees, J. A., Bown, P. R., and Young, J. R.: Photic zone palaeoenvironments of the Kimmeridge Clay Formation (Upper Jurassic, UK) suggested by calcareous nannoplankton palaeoecology, Palaeogeogr. Palaeocl., 235, 110–134, 2006. 

Leng, M. J. and Lewis, J. P.: Bulk C/N ratios and Carbon Isotopes in Estuarine Environments, in: Applications of Paleoenvironmental Techniques in Estuarine Studies, edited by: Weckström, K., Saunders, K., Gell, P., and Skilbeck, G., Developments in Palaeoenvironmental Research, vol. 20, Springer, 2017. 

Macquaker, J. and Gawthorpe, R.: Mudstone lithofacies in the Kimmeridge Clay Formation, Wessex Basin, southern England: implications for the origin and controls of the distribution of mudstones, J. Sediment. Res., 63, 1129–1143, 1993. 

Macquaker, J. H. S., Keller, M. A., and Davies, S. J.: Algal blooms and marine snow: mechanisms that enhance preservation of organic carbon in ancient fine-grained sediments, J. Sediment. Res., 80, 934–942, 2010. 

Morgans-Bell, H. S., Coe, A. L., Hesselbo, S. P., Jenkyns, H. C., Weedon, G. P., Marshall, J. E. A., Tyson, R. V., and Williams, C. J.: Integrated stratigraphy of the Kimmeridge Clay Formation (Upper Jurassic) based on exposures and boreholes in south Dorset, UK, Geol. Mag., 138, 511–539, 2001. 

Neretin, L. N., Böttcher, M. E., Jørgensen, B. B., Volkov, I. I., Lüschen, H., and Hilgenfeldt, K.: Pyritization processes and greigite formation in the advancing sulfidization front in the upper Pleistocene sediments of the Black Sea 1, Geochim. Cosmochim. Ac., 68, 2081–2093, 2004. 

Oschmann, W.: Kimmeridge clay sedimentation – A new cyclic model, Palaeogeogr. Palaeocl., 65, 217–251, 1988. 

Pearce, C. R., Coe, A. L., and Cohen, A. S.: Seawater redox variations during the deposition of the Kimmeridge Clay Formation, United Kingdom (Upper Jurassic): Evidence from molybdenum isotopes and trace metal ratios, Paleoceanography, 25, PA4213,, 2010. 

Pedersen, T. F. and Calvert, S. E.: Anoxia vs. Productivity: What Controls the Formation of Organic-Carbon-Rich Sediments and Sedimentary Rocks, AAPG Bull., 74, 454–466, 1990. 

Percival, L. M. E., Witt, M. L. I., Mather, T. A., Hermoso, M., Jenkyns, H. C., Hesselbo, S. P., Al-Suwaidi, A. H., Storm, M. S., Xu, W., and Ruhl, M.: Globally enhanced mercury deposition during the end-Pliensbachian extinction and Toarcian OAE: A link to the Karoo–Ferrar Large Igneous Province, Earth Planet. Sc. Lett., 428, 267–280, 2015. 

Piper, D. and Calvert, S.: A marine biogeochemical perspective on black shale deposition, Earth-Sci. Rev., 95, 63–96, 2009. 

Powell, J. H.: Jurassic sedimentation in the Cleveland Basin: a review, P. Yorks. Geol. Soc., 58, 21–72, 2010. 

Rawson, P. F., Wright, J. K., Starmer, I., Whitham, F., Hemingway, J., and Greensmith, J. T.: The Yorkshire Coast, Geologists' Association, 2000. 

Rudnick, R. L. and Gao, S.: Composition of the continental crust, chap. 3, in: Treatise on geochemistry, Elsevier, 3, 1–64, 2003. 

Sageman, B. B., Murphy, A. E., Werne, J. P., Ver Straeten, C. A., Hollander, D. J., and Lyons, T. W.: A tale of shales: the relative roles of production, decomposition, and dilution in the accumulation of organic-rich strata, Middle–Upper Devonian, Appalachian basin, Chem. Geol., 195, 229–273, 2003. 

Scaife, J. D., Ruhl, M., Dickson, A. J., Mather, T. A., Jenkyns, H. C., Percival, L. M. E., Hesselbo, S. P., Cartwright, J., Eldrett, J. S., Bergman, S. C., and Minisini, D.: Sedimentary Mercury Enrichments as a Marker for Submarine Large Igneous Province Volcanism? Evidence From the Mid-Cenomanian Event and Oceanic Anoxic Event 2 (Late Cretaceous), Geochem. Geophy. Geosy., 18, 4253–4275, 2017. 

Schieber, J.: Mud re-distribution in epicontinental basins – Exploring likely processes, Mar. Petrol. Geol., 71, 119–133, 2016. 

Scholz, F., Baum, M., Siebert, C., Eroglu, S., Dale, A. W., Naumann, M., and Sommer, S.: Sedimentary molybdenum cycling in the aftermath of seawater inflow to the intermittently euxinic Gotland Deep, Central Baltic Sea, Chem. Geol., 491, 27–38, 2018. 

Scotchman, I. C.: Kerogen facies and maturity of the Kimmeridge Clay Formation in southern and eastern England, Mar. Petrol. Geol., 8, 278–295, 1991. 

Sellwood, B. W. and Valdes, P. J.: Jurassic climates, P. Geologist. Assoc., 119, 5–17, 2008. 

Severmann, S., Lyons, T. W., Anbar, A., McManus, J., and Gordon, G.: Modern iron isotope perspective on the benthic iron shuttle and the redox evolution of ancient oceans, Geology, 36, 487–490, 2008. 

Shanks, A. L.: The abundance, vertical flux, and still-water and apparent sinking rates of marine snow in a shallow coastal water column, Cont. Shelf Res., 22, 2045–2064, 2002. 

Sweere, T., van den Boorn, S., Dickson, A. J., and Reichart, G. J.: Definition of new trace-metal proxies for the controls on organic matter enrichment in marine sediments based on Mn, Co, Mo and Cd concentrations, Chem. Geol., 441, 235–245, 2016. 

Taylor, S. R. and McLennan, S. M.: The continental crust: its composition and evolution, Blackwell, Oxford, 312 pp., 1985. 

Them, T. R., Jagoe, C. H., Caruthers, A. H., Gill, B. C., Grasby, S. E., Gröcke, D. R., Yin, R., and Owens, J. D.: Terrestrial sources as the primary delivery mechanism of mercury to the oceans across the Toarcian Oceanic Anoxic Event (Early Jurassic), Earth Planet. Sc. Lett., 507, 62–72, 2019. 

Trabucho-Alexandre, J.: More gaps than shale: erosion of mud and its effect on preserved geochemical and palaeobiological signals. Strata and Time: Probing the Gaps in Our Understanding, Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 404, 251–270, 2015. 

Tribovillard, N.-P., Desprairies, A., Lallier-Vergès, E., Bertrand, P., Moureau, N., Ramdani, A., and Ramanampisoa, L.: Geochemical study of organic-matter rich cycles from the Kimmeridge Clay Formation of Yorkshire (UK): productivity versus anoxia, Palaeogeogr. Palaeocl., 108, 165–181, 1994. 

Tribovillard, N., Trentesaux, A., Ramdani, A., Baudinet, F., and Riboulleau, A.: Controls on organic accumulation in late Jurassic shales of northwestern Europe as inferred from trace-metal geochemistry, B. Soc. Geol. Fr., 175, 491–506, 2004.  

Tribovillard, N., Algeo, T. J., Lyons, T., and Riboulleau, A.: Trace metals as paleoredox and paleoproductivity proxies: An update, Chem. Geol., 232, 12–32, 2006. 

Tribovillard, N., Algeo, T. J., Baudin, F., and Riboulleau, A.: Analysis of marine environmental conditions based on molybdenum–uranium covariation – Applications to Mesozoic paleoceanography, Chem. Geol., 324–325, 46–58, 2012. 

Tribovillard, N., Hatem, E., Averbuch, O., Barbecot, F., Bout-Roumazeilles, V., and Trentesaux, A.: Iron availability as a dominant control on the primary composition and diagenetic overprint of organic-matter-rich rocks, Chem. Geol., 401, 67–82, 2015. 

Turner, H. E., Batenburg, S. J., Gale, A. S., and Gradstein, F. M.: The Kimmeridge Clay Formation (Upper Jurassic–Lower Cretaceous) of the Norwegian Continental Shelf and Dorset, UK: a chemostratigraphic correlation, Newsl. Stratigr., 1-32, 2019. 

Tyson, R. V.: Sedimentation rate, dilution, preservation and total organic carbon: some results of a modelling study, Org. Geochem., 32, 333–339, 2001. 

Tyson, R. V.: The “Productivity versus Preservation” controversy: Cause, Flaws and Resolution, Sediment. Geol., vol. 82,, 2005. 

Van der Weijden, C. H.: Pitfalls of normalization of marine geochemical data using a common divisor, Mar. Geol., 184, 167–187, 2002. 

Wagner, T., Hofmann, P., and Flögel, S.: Marine black shale deposition and Hadley Cell dynamics: A conceptual framework for the Cretaceous Atlantic Ocean, Mar. Petrol. Geol., 43, 222–238, 2013. 

Wedepohl, K.: Environmental influences on the chemical composition of shales and clays, Phys. Chem. Earth, 8, 307–333, 1971. 

Wedepohl, K. H.: Chemical composition and fractionation of the continental crust, Geol. Rund., 80, 207–223, 1991. 

Wegwerth, A., Eckert, S., Dellwig, O., Schnetger, B., Severmann, S., Weyer, S., Brüske, A., Kaiser, J., Köster, J., Arz, H. W., and Brumsack, H.-J., Redox evolution during Eemian and Holocene sapropel formation in the Black Sea, Palaeogeogr. Palaeocl., 489, 249–260, 2018. 

Wijsman, J. W., Middelburg, J. J., and Heip, C. H.: Reactive iron in Black Sea sediments: implications for iron cycling, Mar. Geol., 172, 167–180, 2001. 

Williams, C. J., Hesselbo, S. P., Jenkyns, H. C., and Morgans-Bell, H. S.: Quartz silt in mudrocks as a key to sequence stratigraphy (Kimmeridge Clay Formation, Late Jurassic, Wessex Basin, UK), Terra Nova, 13, 449–455, 2001. 

Publications Copernicus
Short summary
We present a geochemical and petrographic study of the Kimmeridge Clay Formation from the Cleveland Basin (Yorkshire, UK). Our results indicate that deposition during this interval was very dynamic and oscillated between three distinct modes of sedimentation. In line with recent modelling results, we propose that these highly dynamic conditions were driven by changes in climate, which affected continental weathering, enhanced primary productivity, and led to organic carbon enrichment.
We present a geochemical and petrographic study of the Kimmeridge Clay Formation from the...